![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
This is a quote from the Honourable Frederic R. Coudert, in a debate against Robert Ingersoll. The context is why Ingersoll should be punished for expressing his agnostic beliefs.
A word is an act—an act of the tongue; and why should my tongue go unpunished, and I who wield it mercilessly toward those who are weaker than I, escape, if my arm is to be punished when I use it tyrannously? Whom would you punish for the murder of Desdemona—is it Iago, or Othello? Who was the villain, who was the criminal, who deserved the scaffold—who but free speech? Iago exercised free speech. He poisoned the ear of Othello and nerved his arm and Othello was the murderer—but Iago went scot free. That was a word.
I thought this was interesting from a literary / general judicial point of view! Not least because it ignores the actual plot of Othello.( Read more... )
A word is an act—an act of the tongue; and why should my tongue go unpunished, and I who wield it mercilessly toward those who are weaker than I, escape, if my arm is to be punished when I use it tyrannously? Whom would you punish for the murder of Desdemona—is it Iago, or Othello? Who was the villain, who was the criminal, who deserved the scaffold—who but free speech? Iago exercised free speech. He poisoned the ear of Othello and nerved his arm and Othello was the murderer—but Iago went scot free. That was a word.
I thought this was interesting from a literary / general judicial point of view! Not least because it ignores the actual plot of Othello.( Read more... )
